Sunday, 28 July 2013
It is now more than 20 years since pro-democracy grassroots
organizations led struggles that eventually resulted in the overthrow of
long-serving authoritarian regimes in many countries in Africa.
Since the 1990s, there
have been significant improvements in the transition to democratic
governance in Africa. However, there have also been some major
reversals.
Click on the interactive map above to find out more about Africa's governments.
Unfortunately, some
pre-1990 incumbent leaders (for example, Paul Biya of Cameroon and
Robert Gabriel Mugabe of Zimbabwe) remain in power, despite efforts by
the opposition to unseat them.
In addition, Mali, which
had made significant progress toward deepening and institutionalizing
democracy, suffered major regression, first, by the capture and
subsequent occupation of the northern part of the country by a group of
separatist rebels, and second, by a military coup that ousted its
democratically elected government.
Soldiers also intervened
in Guinea-Bissau, suspended government institutions and proceeded to
engage in activities that seriously undermined the rule of law.
Meanwhile, violent mobilization by ethnic and religious groups continue
to negatively impact governance in Nigeria, Central African Republic,
Kenya, Uganda, and Madagascar.
The failure of national
institutions to grant adequate protection to individual liberties
continues to plague countries such as The Gambia, where a U.N report
says several prison inmates were executed last year without due process of law, and South Africa where the police last year used deadly force against miners who were exercising their rights to strike.
See also: New violence clouds future for South African mines
Despite these setbacks,
there have been significant and spectacular achievements in the
continent's struggle to deepen and institutionalize democracy.
Ghana continues to lead the way. First, after the country's president, John Atta Mills, died in office
in July 2012, he was succeeded, as required by the constitution, by the
country's vice president, John Dramani Mahama. Second, in December
2012, the country held competitive, fair and peaceful elections, which
were won by Mahama. He was subsequently sworn in as the country's
president.
Egypt, Libya, Tunisia, Ivory Coast, Sierra Leone, Lesotho, Guinea
and Malawi have made some gains as they move steadily towards democratic
governance.
John Mbaku
John Mbaku
Finally, Ghana has also
shown significant leadership in openness and transparency in government.
In 2003, Ghana committed to the extractive industries transparency
initiative and has since emerged as a leading example of how governments
can minimize corruption in the management of public revenues from the
extractive sector.
Read also: What Ghana can teach the rest of Africa about democracy
Egypt, Libya, Tunisia,
Ivory Coast, Sierra Leone, Lesotho, Guinea and Malawi have made some
gains as they move steadily towards democratic governance.
Ivory Coast, after a
violent and extremely bloody civil war, inaugurated a new president,
followed by the development of new laws and institutions, especially
those dealing with corruption and openness and transparency in
government. In addition, the country now has a fully functioning
legislative assembly, and the country's security situation, previously
worsened by sectarian strife, has improved significantly.
Sierra Leone, whose
institutions were destroyed by a long and brutal civil war, has seen
restoration of many national institutions and a return to the rule of
law. This is exemplified by the fact that the country's 2012 presidential and parliamentary elections
were free, fair and peaceful and the results were accepted by the
people. The winners went on to form a government which continues to rule
the country in peace.
Senegal also held elections in 2012,
which resulted in the peaceful transfer of power. Since taking office,
the new president, Macky Sall, has made significant efforts to improve
openness and transparency in government, as well as force public
officials to be accountable to the constitution and the people.
Lesotho's governance
system was strengthened by successfully conducting fair and free
elections, which resulted in the peaceful transfer of power. Both Malawi
and Guinea saw some improvements in their governance systems -- in
Guinea, opportunities for civic dialogue improved significantly and in
Malawi, the death of the sitting president was not followed by bloody
chaos; instead, as required by the constitution, the vice president,
Joyce Banda, was inaugurated the new president.
The Arab Spring brought significant improvements to governance structures in Egypt, Libya and Tunisia.
John Mbaku
John Mbaku
The Arab Spring brought
significant improvements to governance structures in Egypt, Libya and
Tunisia. The tragic death of Tunisian street vendor Mohamed Bouazizi, by
self-immolation, brought about a grassroots political movement among
Tunisians that effectively overthrew the country's authoritarian ruler,
Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali.
This movement, which was
subsequently nicknamed the Arab Spring, spread to Egypt and Libya,
resulting in the ouster of long-serving dictatorships in those countries
as well. Elections, considered fair and free, have since been held in
all three countries and each now has a democratically elected
government.
Nevertheless, many
groups within these countries, especially those which historically have
suffered exploitation and persecution at the hands of their governments
(e.g., ethnic and religious minorities, and women) have expressed the
fear that although these new regimes came to power through democratic
elections, they are likely to reject or abandon democracy once they have
had a chance to consolidate their power bases.
Already, such fears
appear to be coming true in Egypt, where the new president, Mohamed
Morsy, has already engaged in extra-constitutional practices to grab
more power for himself.
In addition, the elected
parliament was dissolved by the anachronistic supreme constitutional
court, and the new constitution was hurriedly drafted and done so
through a top-down, elite-driven, non-participatory process.
As a consequence, what
had started as a dynamic grassroots-led program to transform Egypt's
laws and institutions and produce a more effective and relevant
governance architecture, has degenerated into a struggle by entrenched
interests, led by Morsy and his Freedom and Justice party, to further
entrench themselves politically and economically.
In Tunisia, the
revolution, which since the ouster of Ben Ali had been progressing well,
despite opposition from several Islamist groups, suffered significant
regression following the brutal and cowardly assassination of Chokri Belaid, a secularist and staunch critic of the ruling Islamist-led government of Prime Minister Hamadi Jebali.
Meanwhile, the brutal
assassination of the U.S. ambassador and the wanton destruction of
property in Benghazi, the cradle of the Libyan revolution, is indicative
of a still-born transformation, one that had failed to create
institutions capable of guaranteeing the rule of law in Libya.
The many individuals that participated in North Africa's grassroots
revolution ... are frustrated because their revolutions did not achieve
their critical goals.
John Mbaku
John Mbaku
The struggles of
grassroots organizations in Libya, Tunisia and Egypt are symptomatic of
what needs to be done throughout Africa to deepen and institutionalize
democracy.
Read also: Western-style democracy 'not suitable for Africa'?
The many individuals
that participated in North Africa's grassroots revolution to replace
authoritarianism with democracy are frustrated because their revolutions
did not achieve their critical goals -- reconstruction and
reconstitution of anachronistic and dysfunctional state systems
inherited from the ancien régimes to provide legal and judicial systems
that guarantee the just rule of law.
That is, laws and
institutions that protect individuals' rights, including protecting all
citizens from violence directed at them either by state or non-state
actors, and enhance people's ability to engage in productive activities
to create the wealth that they need to fight poverty and improve their
living conditions.
Such laws are consistent
with the provisions of the universal declaration of human rights and
other international human rights instruments. These revolutions, as has
been the case in other African countries, were hijacked by entrenched
opportunists, whose main interest is in preserving the status quo, so
that they can continue to use these anachronistic state structures to
enrich themselves at the expense of their fellow citizens.
In order to advance the
transition to democratic governance in Africa, as well as minimize the
chances of regression, each African country must engage all its relevant
stakeholder groups in state reconstruction through democratic (i.e.,
bottom-up, participatory, inclusive and people-driven) constitution
making to produce institutional arrangements that adequately constrain
civil servants and political elites, enhance the ability of each
country's diverse population groups to coexist peacefully, and create
economic and political environments that maximize entrepreneurial
activities and the creation of wealth.
home
Home